Toy swap vs toy library vs op shop: which is right for your family?
Four ways to refresh your kids' toys without buying new — swapping, borrowing from a toy library, op shops and selling online — compared on cost, effort and what you actually get.
Kids outgrow toys fast, and buying new every time gets expensive and fills the house. There are four common alternatives in Australia: swapping with other families, borrowing from a toy library, donating or buying at an op shop, and selling second-hand online. They suit different families, and many parents end up using two or three of them.
Here's how they compare, and how to pick.
The quick answer
- Want toys to keep, for free? Swap.
- Want a big, rotating range — including expensive or bulky toys — and don't mind returning them? Toy library.
- Just want the old toys gone, fast? Op shop.
- Want some money back for good-quality toys? Sell online.
Side-by-side
| Toy swap | Toy library | Op shop | Selling online | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cost | Usually free | Annual membership (varies by library) | Free to donate; cheap to buy | Free to list; you earn money |
| You keep the toy? | Yes | No — borrow and return | Yes (if buying) | — |
| What you need to give | Toys of your own to offer | Membership, often volunteer shifts | Nothing | Time: photos, messages, meet-ups |
| Range | What local families have | Large, curated, often includes big items | Hit and miss | — |
| Best for | Keeping play fresh at no cost | Trying lots of toys without storing them | Clearing out quickly | Higher-value toys in great condition |
Toy swapping
How it works: you trade toys your child has outgrown for toys that suit them now. Swaps happen informally between friends, at playgroup or council swap events, or through a swap app.
Why families like it:
- It's free, and the toys you get are yours to keep — or to swap again later.
- Your outgrown toys go straight to a child who'll use them, rather than into storage or the bin.
- It naturally matches your child's stage: you trade baby toys for toddler toys, toddler toys for preschool toys.
Watch out for:
- You need something to offer, so it works best once you've built up a few outgrown toys. Our guide on how to declutter kids' toys helps you find them.
- Range depends on what families nearby have.
- You're responsible for checking what you receive. Look for recalls, broken parts and loose batteries before it goes to your child.
SwapToys is built for exactly this: snap a photo of an outgrown toy, see what families in your suburb have listed for your child's age, and arrange a swap at a local park or library. We're opening suburb by suburb — become a founding family to be first in yours.
Toy libraries
How it works: like a book library, but for toys. You pay a membership, borrow a set number of toys for a few weeks, then return them and choose new ones. Find one near you with Toy Libraries Australia's directory.
Why families like it:
- A huge, cleaned and checked range — including big or pricey items like ride-ons, climbing frames and party packs you wouldn't want to buy or store.
- Constant novelty without the clutter: toys go back before they're forgotten.
- Run by and for local families, so it's a great way to meet people.
Watch out for:
- Membership fees vary. WasteSorted WA puts a typical family membership at $65 to $100 a year,2 and City of Unley's toy libraries in South Australia charge families $50 a year to borrow 8 toys at a time.1 Some councils offer free or discounted membership with a concession card. Check your local library's rates.
- Many are volunteer-run, so members are often asked to do occasional duty shifts.2
- Opening hours can be limited, and some close over school holidays.
- Missing pieces matter. Returning a puzzle with pieces missing can mean a fee, so it suits families who can keep track of parts.
Op shops
How it works: donate toys you no longer need to a charity shop such as Salvos Stores or Vinnies, or pick up second-hand toys there cheaply.
Why families like it:
- The fastest way to clear out: one drop-off and it's done.
- Your donation raises money for the charity.
- Buying can be very cheap, and you never know what you'll find.
Watch out for:
- Charities can only accept toys that are clean, complete and safe. Salvos Stores asks that donations aren't broken, damaged or faulty,3 and Vinnies accepts toys and board games only when they're complete.4 Broken toys cost charities money to throw away.
- Rules vary by store and state — some don't accept toys that use button batteries, for example. Call ahead with anything unusual.
- Drop off during opening hours. Goods left outside a closed shop often get damaged or rained on and end up as landfill.
- When buying, the safety checking is up to you — see below.
Selling online
How it works: list toys on Facebook Marketplace, Gumtree or a local buy-swap-sell group, then arrange pick-up or delivery.
Why families like it:
- You get some money back, which is worth it for higher-value items such as large LEGO sets, quality wooden toys, or outdoor play equipment.
Watch out for:
- It takes time: photos, descriptions, replying to messages, and no-shows.
- Low-value toys often aren't worth the effort — bundle them or swap them instead.
- Meet in a public place or use contactless pick-up, and don't share more personal details than you need to.
Which should you choose?
If you're on a tight budget: start with swapping and your local toy library. Together they cover everyday toys you keep and big-ticket toys you borrow, for little or no cost.
If space is your main problem: a toy library is hard to beat — toys go back on a schedule, so the pile never builds up.
If you just need to clear out this weekend: set aside the best few toys to swap or sell, and take the rest to an op shop in one trip.
If your child gets bored quickly: combine a toy library (lots of variety) with a toy rotation at home so old favourites feel new again.
Safety, whichever you choose
Second-hand toys are a great choice, but give each one a quick check before your child plays with it — and before you pass it on:
- Recalls: search the toy on the ACCC's Product Safety Australia recalls list.5
- Batteries: button and coin battery compartments must be secure and screwed shut.
- Small parts and damage: check for cracks, sharp edges, loose magnets and small detachable parts, especially for children under three.
- Clean it: wipe hard toys and wash soft ones.
Frequently asked questions
Is a toy library cheaper than buying toys?
Usually, yes, if you use it regularly. An annual membership is often less than the price of a single large toy, and you can borrow many toys over the year. It depends on your local library's fees and how often you can get there.
Can I swap toys if I don't have many to give?
Yes. Most families have more outgrown toys than they realise — a quick declutter usually turns up a few good swaps. Start small: one toy in, one toy out.
Do op shops take soft toys?
Many do, if they're clean and in good condition, but policies vary by store. Check with your local shop first.
What's the most sustainable option?
Anything that keeps a toy in use for longer. Swapping and toy libraries keep toys moving between families for years; donating to an op shop is next best. Throwing toys away should be the last resort.