SwapToys logo SwapToys

How to declutter kids' toys (without the tears)

A calm, step-by-step way to sort the toy pile, keep what your kids actually play with, and pass the rest on locally — plus where to donate, swap and recycle toys in Australia.

By The SwapToys team · · 7 min read

If your living room looks like a toy shop exploded, you're not alone. Around 220 million toys are sold in Australia every year, and about half of new toys are thrown out within 12 months of purchase.1 Most families don't need fewer toys because toys are bad. They need fewer toys because a smaller, well-chosen set gets played with more.

There's research behind that. In a University of Toledo study, toddlers given 4 toys played with each one for longer and in more varied, creative ways than toddlers given 16 toys.2 It was a small lab study, so treat it as a useful nudge rather than a rule, but it matches what many parents notice at home: less on the floor, more actual play.

This guide walks you through a declutter that doesn't end in a meltdown (yours or theirs), and shows you what to do with everything that leaves the house.

Before you start

Pick your timing. Avoid the week before a birthday or Christmas, or straight after a big change like a new sibling or moving house. A quiet weekend morning works best.

Decide how involved your kids will be. This depends on age:

  • Under 3: do it while they're asleep or out. They won't miss most things, and they can't make the decisions yet.
  • 3 to 6: involve them in small, simple choices ("Which two of these puzzles do you want to keep?"). Avoid open-ended questions like "Do you still want this?" — the answer is almost always yes.
  • 7 and up: let them lead parts of it. Older kids are often surprisingly ruthless, especially if they know their toys are going to another child rather than the bin.

Set yourself up with four boxes or bags, labelled: Keep, Rotate, Pass on, and Recycle/bin.

Step 1: Gather everything in one place

Pull every toy from every room, the car, and the back of the wardrobe into one spot. It's confronting, but seeing the whole lot together is what makes sorting fast. It's also how you find the three identical toy trucks nobody remembers buying.

Do this one category at a time if the full pile is overwhelming — all the puzzles, then all the vehicles, then soft toys.

Step 2: Sort into the four boxes

Work quickly. Give each toy a few seconds and go with your first instinct.

Keep — toys that are played with every week, or that your child would ask about if they disappeared.

Rotate — good toys that just aren't getting attention right now. These go into storage and come back out later (see Step 4). This box is the secret weapon: it lets you clear space without the anxiety of giving things away.

Pass on — toys in good, complete, safe condition that your child has outgrown or never really took to.

Recycle/bin — broken, incomplete, or worn-out toys that nobody else could use either.

Questions that make decisions easier

  • Has it been played with in the last three months?
  • Is it still the right age and stage for my child?
  • Does it have all its pieces, and does it work?
  • Do we have something that does the same job?
  • If it broke tomorrow, would I replace it?

If the answers are mostly "no", it belongs in Pass on or Recycle/bin.

Step 3: Deal with sentimental toys separately

The first teddy, the toy from Grandma, the blocks you played with as a kid — these deserve their own decision. Keep a small "memory box" per child with a strict limit (a single shoebox works well). If something doesn't fit, take a photo of your child with it before it moves on. The photo often holds the memory better than the object in a cupboard does.

Step 4: Set up a simple toy rotation

Put the Rotate box somewhere out of sight — a high shelf, the garage, under a bed. Every two to four weeks, swap a handful of toys out and bring a handful back.

Toys that come back after a break often feel brand new, and you get the "fresh toy" effect without buying anything. Keep the number of toys out at any one time small enough that your child can see everything and pack it away themselves.

Step 5: Pass on the rest

This is where most decluttering stalls: the Pass on bags sit in the boot for six months. Pick one or two of these options and do it the same week.

Swap with local families. Swapping means your outgrown toys go to a child who'll use them, and yours get something new in return — without spending money. You can run a swap with friends or at a playgroup, or use SwapToys, which matches you with families in your suburb.

Give to a toy library. Many toy libraries accept donations of good-quality toys and puzzles. Find your nearest one through Toy Libraries Australia. Call first, as each library decides what it can take.

Donate to an op shop or charity. Most op shops accept clean, complete toys in good condition. Rules vary by store, so check before you drop off — and never leave donations outside a closed shop.

Pass to family and friends. Younger cousins, neighbours, your local parents' group. Easy, but be honest about whether they actually want them.

Recycle what can't be reused. Most plastic toys can't go in your kerbside recycling bin. Big W has run a Toys for Joy collection with TerraCycle, taking worn-out toys for recycling and passing good ones to charity3 — check with your local store whether it's still running and what it accepts. Electronic toys go to your council's e-waste drop-off, and loose batteries can go to a B-cycle drop-off point.

Safety check before anything leaves the house

Passing on a toy means passing on responsibility for it. Before you donate, swap or give a toy away:

  • Check for recalls. Search the toy on the ACCC's Product Safety Australia recalls list.4 Recalled toys shouldn't be passed on.
  • Check battery compartments. Toys with button or coin batteries need a secure compartment that a child can't open. If the cover is broken or missing, recycle the toy instead.
  • Look for broken parts and small pieces. Sharp edges, cracked plastic, loose magnets and small detached parts are a choking or injury risk, especially for children under three.
  • Clean it. Wipe hard toys and wash soft toys before they go.

How to stop the pile coming back

  • One in, one out. When a new toy arrives, one leaves. Kids understand this rule surprisingly quickly.
  • Steer gifts. Suggest experiences, books, art supplies or contributions to one bigger item when relatives ask what to buy.
  • Swap instead of buy. When your child is ready for the next stage, look for a swap before heading to the shops.
  • Repeat every season. A 30-minute mini-declutter every three months stops it from ever becoming a whole-weekend job again.

Frequently asked questions

How many toys should a child have?

There's no magic number. The University of Toledo study compared 4 toys with 16 in a short play session,2 which doesn't translate directly to a whole home. A practical rule: have few enough toys out that your child can see all of them and tidy them up without help, and rotate the rest.

Should I declutter without my kids knowing?

For toddlers, usually yes. For older children, it's better to involve them — secretly removing toys can damage trust, and kids are more likely to let things go when they help decide, especially if they know another child will get to play with them.

What if my child wants something back?

That's what the Rotate box is for. Keep the Pass on bags for a week or two before they leave the house; if nobody asks for anything, they're good to go.

Is it safe to give away second-hand toys?

Yes, as long as you check them first. Look up recalls, check for broken parts and loose batteries, and clean everything. See the safety checklist above.

Sources

  1. Toy Libraries Australia — World Sustainable Toy Day media release (2022), citing research by the Australian Toy Association and Sustainability Victoria.
  2. Dauch, C., Imwalle, M., Ocasio, B. & Metz, A. E. (2018). The influence of the number of toys in the environment on toddlers' play. Infant Behavior and Development, 50, 78–87. Summary: University of Toledo.
  3. Woolworths Group — Big W Toys for Joy (2024).
  4. Product Safety Australia (ACCC) — Recalls.